City Island NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Imagine waking up to the sound of seagulls, walking down to a historic marina, and enjoying a New England-style coastal lifestyle—all while officially living within New York City limits.

Just 1.5 miles long and a half-mile wide, City Island is NYC’s best-kept secret. At City Island Real Estate, we’ve spent over two decades helping families, professionals, and retirees find their perfect piece of this unique waterfront community. Whether you are looking for a sprawling waterfront property, a charming historic bungalow, or a modern condo, we know exactly where to look.

Living on City Island: A Coastal Lifestyle in the Bronx

City Island offers a pace of life you simply cannot find anywhere else in the five boroughs. When you cross the City Island Bridge, the hustle and bustle of the city fades away, replaced by sail-makers, antique shops, and a tight-knit community of neighbors who actually know your name.

Here is what makes buying a home on City Island so special:

Deep Nautical Roots:

With a rich shipbuilding history, the island is a boater's paradise. It is home to renowned institutions like the Morris Yacht and Beach Club and the Harlem Yacht Club.

World-Class Seafood:

People travel from all over the tri-state area to dine on City Island Avenue. As a resident, you get year-round access to local favorites like Johnny's Reef, The Lobster Box, Artie's Steak and Seafood, and the classic City Island Diner.

A True Community Feel:

From the annual Fall Arts & Crafts Fair to the Memorial Day Parade, this is a neighborhood that celebrates together.

The City Island Real Estate Market

Because the island is geographically limited, the real estate market here is exclusive and highly competitive. Properties range from cozy, historic single-family homes on quiet side streets to luxurious waterfront estates with private docks on the Long Island Sound.

For buyers looking for lower-maintenance options, there are also excellent co-ops, condos, and apartments for rent that offer incredible water views and resort-style amenities without the upkeep of a detached home.

Commuting to Manhattan and Beyond

You don’t have to sacrifice city convenience for coastal charm. Commuting from City Island is straightforward and stress-free:

Public Transit:

The Bx29 bus runs directly down City Island Avenue, taking you straight to the Pelham Bay Park station where you can catch the 6 Train into Manhattan.

Express Bus:

The BxM8 express bus offers a comfortable, direct ride into Midtown Manhattan.

By Car:

You are just minutes away from I-95 and the Hutchinson River Parkway, making trips into Westchester, Connecticut, or deeper into NYC incredibly easy.

Ready to Find Your Island Home?

Don’t wait for the perfect waterfront home to show up on Zillow. Let the local experts find it for you first.